Industry News

SB 253 Scope 3 Ruling: What It Means for Branded Merch Suppliers

The Ninth Circuit paused California's value-chain emissions reporting but kept Scope 1 and 2. Here is what that means for the merch supply chain.

Promogator By Promogator Staff • • 4 min read
Share
SB 253 Scope 3 Ruling: What It Means for Branded Merch Suppliers

On November 9, 2026, the federal appeals court for the Ninth Circuit issued a ruling that changes what large companies must tell California about their greenhouse gas emissions. For anyone who sells to big corporate buyers, the headline is the court's treatment of SB 253 Scope 3 reporting: the value-chain disclosure that would have pulled suppliers, including branded merchandise suppliers, into their customers' emissions reports. Here is what the court decided, what it did not decide, and how merch buyers and suppliers should respond.

What the court decided

California's SB 253 requires large companies doing business in the state to report their emissions in three groups. Scope 1 covers emissions from sources a company owns or controls. Scope 2 covers emissions from the energy it buys. Scope 3 covers indirect emissions across its value chain, including its suppliers and customers. A companion law, SB 261, requires reports on climate-related financial risk.

According to the court's published opinion, the panel left the Scope 1 and Scope 2 requirements in place, holding that they likely survive a First Amendment challenge at this stage. It reached the opposite view on Scope 3 and on SB 261, finding both likely unconstitutional, and reversed the lower court's refusal to block them. It sent the case back to the district court to decide whether the Scope 3 provisions can be separated from the rest of SB 253.

Two points are easy to miss. First, this is a preliminary injunction ruling, not a final judgment. A client alert from Crowell & Moring stresses that the decision should not be described as permanently striking down either requirement. Second, the Scope 1 and 2 reporting deadline of November 10, 2026 set by the California Air Resources Board stayed in effect, according to the same alert.

Promogator catalog photo of Patch rPET Knit Beanie With Cuff
Promogator catalog photo: Patch rPET Knit Beanie With Cuff (SKU HIT-1066). A cuffed knit beanie made from recycled polyester. The catalog listing notes that the patch, label and thread are not rPET, the kind of detail an emissions or materials questionnaire may ask about.

Why SB 253 Scope 3 mattered to merch suppliers

SB 253 applies only to very large companies: the law's revenue threshold is more than one billion in annual revenue. Most promotional products buyers will never file a report themselves. The concern for the supply chain was Scope 3. Purchased goods, including branded apparel, drinkware, bags and event giveaways, fall inside a large company's value chain, so a reporting company preparing Scope 3 figures would likely need information from the businesses it buys from.

PPAI's November 2026 regulatory roundup summed up the practical position for the industry: Scope 1 and 2 reporting are still required, while Scope 3, which pulls the whole supply chain into scope for covered companies, is under a partial preliminary injunction and not currently required.

Promogator catalog photo of FSC® Mix DuraHyde Recycled Jr. Zippered Padfolio
Promogator catalog photo: FSC® Mix DuraHyde Recycled Jr. Zippered Padfolio (SKU PCNA-0600-06). A zippered padfolio with an FSC Mix writing pad. Product-level material facts like this are easier to supply when a customer asks than emissions estimates are.

What buyers and suppliers should do now

The pause on SB 253 Scope 3 does not mean sustainability questions will disappear. Many large companies set their own supplier targets, and the district court still has to rule on severability. A sensible response is to keep the records you would need either way.

  • Know what your products are made of. Keep material, recycled-content and country-of-origin details for each item you order regularly, and keep the supplier's own wording.
  • Track how goods travel. Note the shipping mode and origin for large orders. Freight is a common line in value-chain estimates.
  • Avoid broad green claims. If a corporate client asks you to describe a giveaway as low-carbon or climate-friendly, ask what supports that claim before it goes on a proof or a product card.
  • Watch the next step. The district court's severability decision, and any further appeal, will decide whether Scope 3 returns.
Promogator catalog photo of 15W Recycled Aluminum Wireless Charger
Promogator catalog photo: 15W Recycled Aluminum Wireless Charger (SKU HIT-25162). A 15W wireless charger whose catalog listing says it is made of recycled aluminum and plastic. A specific material statement is more useful to a sustainability team than a general "eco" label.

The bigger picture

For merch buyers, the SB 253 Scope 3 ruling buys time rather than closing the topic. Large customers that already ask suppliers for materials and sourcing data are likely to keep asking, and buyers who can answer clearly will find those conversations easier. For related state rules, see our guides to California's textile EPR law and packaging EPR laws. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Sources

Written with AI assistance and reviewed by Promogator Staff. Our editorial standards

Share this article

Promogator Staff

Written and reviewed by the Promogator team. Our editorial standards

Products mentioned in this article

Live pricing — updated Nov 18, 2026.

Need a quote?

Tell us what you have in mind and we will come back with pricing, lead times and options — no obligation.

No spam. We use your details only to answer this request.

Keep reading

Compare /

Compare Products

Highlighted rows = products differ on this attribute